Ogallala Bay Rum

Let's add this to your cart
$
Item 29206
Item 29206
(479)
Ogallala Bay Rum
Product ImageProduct Image
Ogallala Bay Rum from Duluth Trading Company is an invigorating scent that smells the way bay rum used to.

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
Ogallala Bay Rum
 
4.3

(based on 479 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (276)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (123)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (33)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (19)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (28)

88%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Pros

  • Pleasant scent (181)
  • Clean scent (162)
  • Clean feel (133)
  • Easy to use (127)
  • Good value (105)

Cons

  • Strong scent (19)
  • Unpleasant scent (12)
  • Bad smell (9)
  • Nicks and cuts (4)

Best Uses

  • Daily use (178)
  • Everyday use (174)
  • Travel (55)
  • Special occasions (51)
  • Sensitive areas (37)
    • Reviewer Profile:
    • Clean shaven (242), Beard wearer (67), Goatee wearer (67), Survivalist / minimalist (40), Scruffy look (28)
    • Hair Texture:
    • Fine hair (115), Coarse hair (80)
    • Skin Type:
    • Normal (36), Combination (6), Oily (5), Dry (3)

Reviewed by 479 customers

Sort by

Displaying reviews 1-10

Back to top

Previous | Next »

 
5.0

Best Bay Rum Out There!

By Bay Rummer

from Castle Rock, CO

About Me Minimalist

Pros

  • Smells Great

Cons

    Best Uses

    • Daily Use

    Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

    I think either you're a bay rum fan or you are not! If you're a fan, I think this is the best Bay Rum I have yet to find on the market. My bathroom cabinet had no less than 6 different bottles of Bay Rum in it. While I've had a favorite over the years, this one knocked my socks off. Most Bay Rum scents would fairly quickly vanish within a short time of application, but this scent stays with you throughout the day. I've got to imagine it's due to the quality and quantity of oils used. I have yet to find a Bay Rum of better quality.

    • Skin Type:
    • Normal

    Comment on this review

     
    3.0

    Scent a little diferent than I thought it would be

    By Stretch

    from Stephens City, VA

    About Me Minimalist

    See all my reviews

    Verified Buyer

    Pros

    • Soothes Skin

    Cons

    • Bad Smell

    Best Uses

    • Daily Use

    Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

    One needs to get used to the scent. It was a little different that I expected.

    • Skin Type:
    • Oily

    Comment on this review

     
    5.0

    Refreshing!

    By Madkins007

    from Nebraska

    About Me Minimalist

    Pros

    • Lightweight
    • Smells Great
    • Soothes Skin

    Cons

      Best Uses

      • Daily Use

      Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

      Maybe a bit clove-y smelling, but I and my wife like it. I don't think it lasts very long on me but may just be me. At my age (55), I rather appreciate some of the classic scents and products, but I suspect a younger guy may not like it so much.

      • Skin Type:
      • Combination

      Comment on this review

       
      2.0

      Great gift idea

      By NanookWI

      from Fairbanks, AK

      About Me Minimalist

      Pros

      • Nice Bottle

      Cons

      • Bad Smell

      Best Uses

        Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

        My step-dad grew up in the 50s and a lot of the reviews I read talked about how the scent reminded guys of an "old-time" barber shop, so I bought a bottle as a gift. Step-dad didn't care for it and mom made him dump it out.

        • Skin Type:
        • Dry

        Comment on this review

         
        1.0

        No barber shop I've ever been in ....

        By Just your average guy

        from Colorado Springs, CO

        Pros

        • Quick Return Processing

        Cons

        • Bad Smell

        Best Uses

          Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

          First review on Duluth a Trading and I have to give this a one star rating .... it's horrible .... absolutely horrible ...... grab a handful of clove spice and rub it over your face ..... now multiple the strong oder by 4 ...... I've been in the old barber shops and this is NOT the smell I remember ....

          I know your going to buy this anyway thinking how all the positive reviews can't be wrong ..... THEY ARE WRONG ..... I have no explanation .... Why so many positive reviews, I don't know .... trust me on this one ......

          Comment on this review

           
          5.0

          Best Aftershave

          By Steve

          from New Braunfels, TX

          About Me Minimalist

          Verified Buyer

          Pros

          • Smells Great
          • Soothes Skin

          Cons

            Best Uses

            • Daily Use

            Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

            This is the best aftershave I've ever found. Smells great and fits in any situation.

            • Skin Type:
            • Normal

            Comment on this review

             
            2.0

            Having fun with this one

            By Keith the fun guy

            from Elbert, Colorado

            About Me Minimalist

            Pros

            • Fun To Re-gift

            Cons

            • Bad Smell

            Best Uses

              Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

              Received as a father's day gift. My wife sprinkled some on me and I started coughing. Can't get it off. Repugnant! We started chasing each other around the room with it and I lost. Put it back in the box and am going to re-gift it to my son-in-law for XMas. Think this is going to be a yearly tradition. Can't wait to see who my son-in-law re-gifts it to next year. I would have returned it, but we're having too much fun with it.

              • Skin Type:
              • Normal

              Comment on this review

               
              4.0

              Cowboy up!

              By Dan the Man

              from Northwest Ohio

              About Me Minimalist

              See all my reviews

              Verified Buyer

              Pros

              • Smells Great
              • Use As Much As Desired

              Cons

              • Definitely Shake Well

              Best Uses

              • After A Long Hard Day

              Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

              Smells great! I mean, who WOULDN'T want to smell like a cowboy on a Saturday night. A hint of leather scent to compliment the fresh-earned suntan for that day's effort of mowing, digging, moving dirt, swinging a hammer, splitting wood, etc...

              The only thing more refreshing than a shower after a long, hard day is following it with a slap of this (cheeks AND chest!) and an ice-cold beverage with the Little Lady! Giddy-Up!!!

              • Skin Type:
              • Normal

              Comment on this review

               
              5.0

              So glad I found it

              By Ron

              from Bella Vista, AR

              See all my reviews

              Verified Buyer

              Pros

              • Moisturizes
              • Non-Greasy
              • Smells Great
              • Soothes Skin

              Cons

                Best Uses

                • Daily Use

                Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

                Almost daily use
                Just a little is all it takes
                Manly smell

                • Skin Type:
                • Oily

                Comment on this review

                (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

                 
                1.0

                Not what I expected

                By Matt

                from Brooklyn, NY

                Pros

                  Cons

                  • Bad Smell

                  Best Uses

                    Comments about Ogallala Bay Rum:

                    I love Duluth Trading and shop here often. Generally everything I get from here is high quality and I have loved the products.

                    But this is the first time I felt the need to get up here and write a review. I'm very confused by the other positive reviews for this product. The smell is very strong and smells very much like 'medicine'. I was surprised at how bad it was. I even tried shaking it a bit and leaving the cap off for a little while to let it breathe, didn't help at all.

                    It's very over powering and just flat out does not smell good. I even let me fiancé smell it thinking that maybe it was me, she looked at me like I was crazy and said "why would you buy that?"

                    Usually even if the smell is 'OK' I would have given it a chance for a couple weeks, but this just makes you shake your head and say 'what were they thinking?'.

                    Will not be buying again.

                    Comment on this review

                    Displaying reviews 1-10

                    Back to top

                    Previous | Next »

                    placeholder
                    placeholder
                    placeholder